Maruti Swift 2011 Petrol Vs Honda Jazz 2011– Which Is Better And Why?

18

Honda SIEL India has recently revealed its facelifted Honda Jazz 2011 in India at jaw-dropping prices starting at Rs. 5.5 Lakhs ex-showroom Delhi. This price drop has brought Honda Jazz in competition of many other existing hatchback’s price bracket in India. With these prices, it is all set to eat a share of the sales pie of hatchback to a greater extent now. In Car Blog India Comparison series, we will today compare it with the hot hatch from India, the all new Maruti Swift 2011 which is already making a lot of news with high bookings even before it was officially launched. Since both the cars have been launched in India, this is a good time to check which one is a better deal.

maruti-swift-2011-vs-honda-jazz-2011

Maruti Swift 2011 Exteriors Vs Honda Jazz 2011 Exteriors

Maruti Swift 2011 Dimension

  • Length = 3850 mm
  • Width = 1695mm
  • Height = 1510mm
  • Wheelbase = 2430

Honda Jazz 2011 Dimensions

  • Length = 3900 mm
  • Width = 1695mm
  • Height = 1535mm
  • Wheelbase = 2530

Maruti Swift 2011 has got improved exteriors and is larger than the older generation Maruti Swift. The new Swift has got better looking front fascia, more attractive headlamps, tail lamps, a new rear hatch and overall much better than the previous Swift in many subtle ways. It has aesthetic appeal of its own and looks good in absolute terms.

Honda Jazz on the other hand looks much different and out of the contemporary, just like Swift is a non-contemporary design. Jazz is like a water drop design which seems inspired from the aerodynamic rain drop and characterizes the high quality of Honda engineering capabilities. The front and rear fascia is more attractive compeered to Swift also there is more space inside as the Jazz is larger in length as well as height. Intelligent packaging of Jazz gives it much larger interior space and it has also got a larger wheelbase compared to Swift 2011.

Both cars are good looking, but Honda Jazz impresses me more in terms of exterior looks.

Maruti Swift 2011 Interiors Vs Honda Jazz 2011 Interiors

maruti swift 2011 interiors

image – Maruti Swift 2011 Interiors

Maruti Swift 2011 interiors are of better quality than the previous Swift and plastic quality is also much improved. The new dashboard gives a better and sleeker feel. All in all the dashboard and interiors look better than the old gen Swift, and has been kept in black and grey tone for sporty looks.

Honda Jazz 2011 (8)

image- Honda Jazz Interiors

Honda Jazz 2011 (3)

image- Honda Jazz Interiors

Honda Jazz on the other hand comes with beige-black and blue-black interiors. The dashboard of Jazz looks very premium and is made with good quality of plastics. Comes loaded with loads of good features like the reclining rear seats, Integrated Audio system with aux and USB, auto folding outside rear view mirrors in top variant etc..

In terms of Interiors, we find Jazz to be much better compared to the Maruti Swift 2011.

Maruti Swift 2011 Petrol Engine Vs Honda Jazz 2011 Engine

Maruti Swift 2011 Engine Specifications

  • Improved K12 1.2 Litre MPFI Petrol Engine
  • Dual VVTI Technology
  • 4 Cylinder, Displacement 1197 CC
  • Max power of 86 BHP @ 6000 RPM
  • Max torque of 114 Nm @ 4000 RPM
  • 5 Speed Manual transmission
  • ARAI Certified mileage of 18.6 KMPL

Honda Jazz 2011 Engine Specifications

  • 4 Cylinder SOHC i-VTEC Engine
  • 16 Valve (4 per cylinder) MPFI Petrol Engine
  • Engine Displacement 1198 CC
  • Max power of 88.8 BHP @ 6200 RPM
  • Max torque of 110 Nm @ 4800 RPM
  • ARAI Certified fuel efficiency of 16.7 KMPL
  • 5 Speed Manual transmission

Considering the engine specifications, both these cars come with a 1.2 Litre MPFI Engine which deliver almost same power output and torque. The improved K series engine from Suzuki and i-VTEC engine from Honda are strong contenders. With Honda Engine delivering slightly higher power at same RPM and slightly less torque at higher RPM means that Swift engine may give you a slightly better punch considering the fact that both the cars have almost same kerb weight.

Maruti Swift 2011 Petrol Handling and Performance Vs Honda Jazz 2011 Petrol Handling and Performance

In handling, Swift is the leader of its segment, but Jazz is not far behind. While Swift Petrol is quite agile, rev-happy and handles very sharply, Honda Jazz is also very smooth, refined and handles quite well. In absolute terms, both cars handle very well, but when it comes to comparison, Swift come out to be more sharp handler with stiffer suspension tuning while Honda Jazz is slightly behind it as it is tuned for softer suspension, thus lags slightly on sharp handling on high speed cornering etc.

If I have to pick one of the two, Swift is better, but not far better, just a little better.

Maruti Swift 2011 Petrol Price Vs Honda Jazz 2011 Petrol Price

All prices mentioned below are ex-showroom Delhi

Maruti Swift 2011 Petrol Price In India

  • Maruti Swift Lxi Petrol is priced at Rs. 4.22 Lakhs
  • Maruti Swift Vxi Petrol is priced at Rs. 4.76 Lakhs
  • Maruti Swift Zxi Petrol is priced at Rs. 5.53 Lakhs

Honda Jazz 2011 Petrol Price In India

  • Honda Jazz 2011 S is priced at Rs. 5.50 Lakhs
  • Honda Jazz 2011 Select is priced at Rs. 5.75 Lakhs
  • Honda Jazz 2011 X is priced at Rs. 6.06 Lakhs

Comparing on price front, if you want a no frill value for money car without any safety and features and gadgetry, the Swift Petrol LXi variant is priced way below the base variant of Jazz. The reason why Jazz is priced higher is the fact that Jazz is fully loaded with all the safety features and gadgetry right form the base variant with just a few features which are missing from base variant. However, in Swift, most of the safety features and gadgetry are missing in Lxi and Vxi. In terms of safety, Jazz base variant is as loaded as the top end Swift Zxi which is priced at Rs. 3,000 more compared to the Jazz base variant.

So the bottom line is Jazz gives you more value for your money, but does not have a low end model like Swift without frills. If you don’t mind spending extra bucks for safety and features, Jazz provides much better package in a reasonable price. Comparing the Swift Zxi with Jazz base model, the Jazz provides almost all the features which Swift top end variant has except for driver seat height adjust, alloy wheels, climate control and fog lamps, for which the next variant of Jazz, the Jazz Select priced higher by about Rs. 25,000 provides some of them with chrome grille, alloy wheels and additionally reclining rear seats etc.

Car Blog India verdict – Maruti Swift 2011 Petrol Vs Honda Jazz 2011 Petrol

If you are not on a budget and considering a car with safety features like ABS and Airbags, I would suggest you to go for Honda Jazz as its comfortable, safe, refined, larger and priced right after the 2011 facelift has been announced.

However, if sharp handling is your top priority and you can do with less comfort and features, Swift is the car for you. Swift will suit your needs more if you are looking for a lower priced car without ABS and airbags as Jazz does not offer any such variants.

check out more-

Maruti Swift 2011 Petrol Vs Hyundai i20 Petrol

Maruti Swift 2011 Diesel Vs Hyundai i20 Diesel

Maruti Swift 2011 Diesel Vs Ford Figo Diesel

Maruti Swift 2011 Petrol Vs Ford Figo Petrol

Toyota Etios Liva Vs Maruti Suzuki Swift and Maruti Swift 2011 New Model

Love to read our updates? Get them via Email for FREE. Limited time offer, click here to subscribe.

18 COMMENTS

  1. Jazz looks more elegant and is more aerodynamic. The long winsdhield gives a great feel from inside after holding the steering. The bigger windows allow better viewing area for all. Also, no matter what people say, they are going to need space and jazz will impress anybody after knowing what one can do with the “Magic Seats”. The color options are also better than offered in the Swift. Urban Titanium WOW! Thanks to my friend who informed me on time that Jazz was now affordable. I had almost booked the swift. Now I don’t have to regret. See you soon Jazz!

  2. How is the after sales service and availability of parts and cost?Jazz is good,but being in a transferable job, availability of all India after-sales network is crucial.Maruti is known for low cost of ownership.Anybody can tell their experience with Honda in general and Jazz in particular,if possible.

  3. Dear All

    JAZZ is the car for indian conditions. Engine silent, crisp and excellant. Space and seating very generous. Luggage compartment big for a baby elephant. Safety features perfect for a safe drive in city or on a highway. Driving position picture perfect. Interiors very pleasant and not castroprobic like the SWIFT.

    I bought my jazz just before the price decrease. But I never regret buying this car. This is value for money. We indians think cheaper car is value for money. Jazz deserves the price tag then and even now.

  4. Dear All

    As regards after sales service HONDA ARE THE BEST IN TERMS OF QUALITY. More service centres (quantity) does not mean better service (quality).

    Watch out MARUTI

    VERY PROFESSIONAL.
    STAFF POLITE.
    AVAILABLITY OF SPARES NOT A PROBLEM

    JUST FOR IT.

  5. Jazz is anyday a better option n after the 2 lakh price slash theres no reason y i wouldn’t buy a jazz.It looks better than swift, Its got better interiors than swift n is probably the biggest hatch in the country today.Also considering the increase in waiting period of the new swift i.e 6-9 months, I’d choose jazz over swift with my eyes closed!

  6. hi rohit,
    I have heard it from most of the people and i am thinking to buy this car. but after hearing such type of braking problems . I want to discuss first about it that is this problem is in swift zxi or not?

  7. JAZZ IS THE BEST OPTION, MARUTI SWIFT IS JUST MADE A DREAM TO COME TRUE AS JAZZ IS JAZZY AND BEST OPTION AS COMPARED TO SWIFT. IN INDIA PEOPLE DONOT TAKE THERE OWN DECISIONS BUT GO FOR WHAT OTHERS ARE DOING. JAZZ IS THE BEST JUSTIFIED IN BOTH AS ITS HONDA AND MARUTI CAN NEVER BECOME HONDA IN TERMS OF QUALITY AND RELIABILITY.

    GO FOR HONDA. JAZZ KI JAI HO/-

  8. i own both… a jazz 2011 model and a swift 2009 model… trust me jazz is better then swift in all aspects…

    Ashish

  9. hi admin!
    i am plannin to buy a hatch back aftr 4 months and and m trying to make my mind for honda jazz. (luxury is a must for me but i desire a moderate or less maintenance and running cost) but i’m still confused as to whether i should go in for a diesel car or a petrol variant of some other manufacturer (blv honda jazz diesel is getting launched in india soon). my expected running would be around 10-15 km per day on an avg however intermitently aftr 4-5 months i do go on long rides or self drive holidays clocking about 2000-2500 km in the route. i plan to keep the car with me for at least 6 yrs and then may be i upgrade… plz suggest the type of engine i should go for and also a comment on the make and models suggested by u.

    thanks n regards

    yogesh

  10. I would say New swift Rules than Jazz, first TOC is less in swift, second the resale value, Third Mileage, fourth parts of maruti are far cheaper than Honda, Think what will you do after the free service and Guarantee gets over, Ask any Honda user you would know the Answer

  11. Now a days maintenance is not a big problem for any of the cars, be it a Swift or Jazz. Because most of the petrol engines are trouble free up to 1 – 2 lacks. That too honda engines can easily run up to 3 lacks KMS without major issues.
    I would say for a premier feel one should go for Honda and it is a perfect family car. Swift is equally good car, but doesn’t offer good boot space and refinement, for younger generation who would like to modify the engine and enjoy the driving, Swift suits them a lot.

  12. very splendidly explained everythings in ur article. I am confused between Honda All New Jazz and Honda Amaze in petrol version. Plzzz make it clear which one is better….Thanks.
    Regards,
    Dinesh

  13. Hi Dinesh,
    thanks for the appreciation. Well, it depends on what you’re exactly looking for. One’s a budget sedan and other’s a premium hatchback. Final choice can be based only on the exact needs.

    Best Regards

  14. This is a joke that Jazz interior dashboard is better than swift. Just find the two picture of the dashboard of both cars and compare it or go outside and look and define which is better, which is more luxury likely. Sit in the driver seat or passenger seat, u will feel. Check out what happening to Jazz dashboard after using some period. I found that on my friend car, Jazz and I decided to go for Swift surely.

    Compare the price with same or lesser price in swift, you will get Push start, Side Mirror On/Off, Digital AC and much more in swift while jazz has many options which are not come along with the original car.
    Just make a features list of their basic grade and then you will see what is worth to go.

LEAVE A REPLY