Comparison of new Honda BRV with Hyundai Creta and Renault Duster

15

Honda Cars India is about to step into the small SUV territory in India, a territory ruled by the Renault Duster until last year and now, the Hyundai Creta. Leading Honda’s charge will be the BRV that was unveiled globally in 2015 and made its India debut at this year’s Auto Expo. A derivative of the Brio‘s platform, the BRV has been specifically designed for markets such as ours, where the HR-V would have turned out to be too expensive. The BR-V has now been launched in India priced in the INR 8.75 lakhs – Rs. 12.90 lakhs bracket. Taking the fight to the Creta and Duster will not be an easy task. The former managed to gather over 1 lac bookings since its launch 8 months back while the latter recently got a major facelift. Will the upcoming SUV from Honda be able to challenge the two? Find out here in our Honda BRV vs Hyundai Creta vs Renault Duster comparison of specifications and prices.

honda brv vs hyundai creta vs renault duster - comparison of specifications, mileage, prices

Also SeeBR-V Prices | BR-V vs Mobilio | BR-V vs Vitara Brezza vs EcoSport vs Nexon | New Honda Civic

Honda BRV vs Hyundai Creta vs Renault Duster Comparison – Price

  Hyundai Creta Renault Duster Honda BR-V*
Petrol INR 9.16-12.89 lacs INR 8.47-9.27 lacs INR 8.75-11.99 lacs
Diesel INR 10.07-14.43 lacs INR 9.27-13.57 lacs INR 9.90-12.90 lacs

*estimated ex-showroom price.

In terms of pricing, there is a difference of around 50,000-70,000 between the Creta and the Duster. Also, the top spec AWD Duster is considerably cheaper than the top of the line Creta that misses out on an AWD setup. Even the Duster automatic is priced lower than the Hyundai giving it a slight advantage in terms of price. Honda priced the BR-V between the Duster and the Creta, but these prices are introductory and likely to go up in the coming months. The petrol  Duster, though cheaper than the Creta, is not available in the top spec RxZ trim. The Duster misses out on a petrol automatic variant and the Hyundai Creta will the be only SUV with petrol and diesel automatic variants.

Also See – 2016 Honda BR-V – Another Failure from Honda Cars India?

Honda BRV vs Hyundai Creta vs Renault Duster Comparison of Features

There isn’t much that will set these three apart in terms of equipment offered once the Honda BRV is launched. However, it will become the only SUV in its segment that will come with a third row of seats, which would add to the BRV’s practicality. All SUVs get dual front airbags and ABS, 2-DIN infotainment setup, auto aircon, alloys wheels, rear AC vents and more. Only the Creta comes with 6 airbags as an option. Honda’s BR-V misses out on a touchscreen infotainment system and reversing sensors or camera.

honda-br-v-suv-photos- (5)
The Honda BR-V gets three rows of seats

Also See – Hyundai Creta Test Drive Review | New Renault Test Drive Review

Honda BRV vs Hyundai Creta vs Renault Duster Comparison- Specifications

Diesel 

Hyundia Creta Renault Duster Honda BR-V
Type 1.4 L Diesel 1.6 L Diesel 1.5 L Diesel 1.5 L Diesel
Displacement 1,396 cc 1,582cc 1,461cc 1498 cc
Power 89 bhp 126 bhp 84/108 bhp 100 bhp
Torque 224 Nm 259 Nm 200/248 Nm 200 Nm
Transmission 6-speed MT 6-speed MT/ 6-speed AT 5-speed/6-speed MT or 6-speed AMT 6-speed MT
Mileage 21.38 kpl 19.67/17.01 kpl 19.87/19.64 kpl 21.9 kpl

Petrol

Hyundia Creta Renault Duster Honda BR-V
Type 1.6 L Petrol 1.6 L Petrol 1.5 L Petrol
Displacement 1591 cc 1598cc 1497 cc
Power 122 bhp 102 bhp 117 bhp
Torque 154 Nm 145 Nm 145 Nm
Transmission 6-speed MT/AT 5-speed MT 6-speed MT/CVT
Mileage 15.29 kpl 13.6 kpl 16 kpl/15.4 kpl

The Honda BR-V shares its powertrains with the City and Mobilio, which means it is powered by a 1.5 L i-DTEC diesel and a 1.5 L i-VTEC petrol engine. Honda will also offer the petrol BR-V with an optional CVT. The Hyundai Creta gets three engine options – 1.4 L Diesel, 1.6 L Diesel and 1.6 L Petrol. The 1.6 L diesel is available with a 6-speed automatic. Renault offers two engine options with the Duster – 1.6 L Petrol and 1.5 L diesel. The latter is available with either a power output of 85 PS or 110 PS. The 110 PS diesel comes with an optional 6-speed AMT now. As of now, Honda doesn’t seem to have any plans of offering the diesel variants of the BRV with an automatic gearbox, which could turn out to be a disadvantage. Only the Renault Duster gets an AWD system.

2016-renault-duster-facelift-review-images (6)
Only SUV with AWD

Also See – Honda BR-V vs Honda City

Honda BRV vs Hyundai Creta vs Renault Duster Dimensions

  Honda BR-V Hyundai Creta Renault Duster
Length 4456 mm 4270 mm 4315 mm
Width 1735 mm 1780 mm 1822 mm
Height 1666 mm 1630 mm 1695 mm
Wheelbase 2660 mm 2590 mm 2673 mm
Ground Clearance 210 mm 190 mm 205 mm

Honda BRV vs Hyundai Creta vs Renault Duster Comparison of Design

Honda seems to have used the Mobilio as the base for the design of the BR-V. However, they have done a good job of giving the BRV its own identity by completely redesigning the front and back ends and raising the ride height as well. The resemblance to the Mobilio is most evident in the BRV’s side profile, especially the kink in the window line. Other design highlights include body cladding all around, projector headlamps, LED pilot lamps, etc. However, it still looks more like an MPV than an SUV. The modifications made to the Duster’s exterior as part of the recent facelift have injected some freshness into the design. It is still one of the most butch looking SUVs among the three. As far as the Creta is concerned, the sharp aggressive lines combined with a bold grille, split tail lamps, etc ensure the Hyundai small SUV is a properly good looking car.

The interiors of the Honda BRV are almost identical to what we have seen on the recently facelifted Honda Amaze. Which is a good thing considering the Brio’s interiors always felt a bit quirky and low rent. The facelifted Duster now features a black and brown interior colour scheme and better quality materials. However, quality is still not up to the mark. Speaking of which, the Hyundai Creta’s interior quality is top notch. It comes with a well designed black beige cabin that impresses in terms of space and quality.

Honda BRV vs Hyundai Creta vs Renault Duster Comparison- Fuel Mileage

Here’s a comparison table of the ARAI-tested fuel mileage figures of the Honda BRV, Hyundai Creta and Renault Duster –

Petrol Diesel
Honda BRV 16 kpl (MT), 15.4 kpl (AT) 21.9 kpl
Hyundai Creta 15.29 kpl (MT/AT), 21.38 kpl (1.4 MT), 19.67 kpl (1.6 MT), 17.07 kpl (1.6 AT)
Renault Duster 13.6 kpl (MT) 17.89 kpl (MT)), 19.6 kpl (AT)

Verdict

The popularity of small SUVs is constantly on the rise, a fact that has been highlighted by the stellar sales figures of the Hyundai Creta. The arrival of the Honda BR-V should shake things up a bit. Honda enjoys a very strong brand image in India, which, coupled with the BR-V’s practical nature, should help push sales.

Design – The Renault Duster looks butch, and the recent facelift has added some freshness to it. The Creta features more modern exteriors and interiors. The BRV boasts of a good looking front end and decent interiors. However, there are enough similarities between the Mobilio and the BR-V to make this car look less exciting. Also, the Amaze-like dashboard is a let-down in a car as pricey a the BRV.

Features – All SUVs almost evenly matched in terms of features. The BRV gets 7 seats, which gives it an advantage over the other two. However, it misses out on a touchscreen, parking sensors and reverse camera. Hyundai offers the top-spec Creta with 6-airbags.

Specifications – The BRV will not be available in a diesel automatic variant, something the other two can boast of. Only the Duster is available with an AWD system. Also, the 1.5-litre iDTEC from Honda is unrefined and is a mediocre performer. In comparison, both the Duster and the Creta have better outright performance.

Price – Honda isn’t exactly known for its aggressive pricing, as evident from the prices of the BRV. For now, it is priced between the Creta and Duster, but it will go up in the coming months.

honda brv vs hyundai creta vs renault duster - comparison of specifications, mileage, prices

Honda will launch the BRV in India on May-5, 2016. We will be able to give you a more definitive verdict once the official prices and specifications have been revealed.

So stay tuned to CarBlogIndia for updates on the Honda BRV vs Hyundai Creta vs Renault Duster. What do you have to say about our Honda BRV vs Hyundai Creta vs Renault Duster comparison? Do share your views in the comments section below. Also, what’s your say on the Honda BRV vs Hyundai Creta vs Renault Duster comparison? Which one of these upcoming small SUVs in India are you waiting for?

Love to read our updates? Get them via Email for FREE. Limited time offer, click here to subscribe.

15 COMMENTS

  1. Duster should have come up with an all new design rather than a facelift,it is almost a 5 year old design. I dont think new Duster can match the sales number of creta despite it being a better car when it comes to ride and handling. Lot depends on the price of BRV, if they place it higher than the Creta then the response might go the Mobilio way. For now, it looks like Creta will be the number 1 compact SUV for a couple of years at least.

  2. I would have liked a 1.8 L petrol engine for Honda BRV also additional features in contemporary SUV would have given a edge. Honda should have launched a SUV to compete with Toyota Innova . Giving cosmetic upgrades to a Honda Mobilio would not serve any purpose.

  3. please suggest me in one word, which SUV is best to buy from the following:

    BRV
    Creta
    Duster

  4. please suggest me in one word, which SUV is best while comparing price and average to buy from the following:

    BRV
    Creta
    Duster

  5. The lack of features which everyone complains in Honda Br-V is simply the touch screen infotainment system and rear parking sensors. If you insist on that, Honda itself offers the same features for additional pricing ( which is why Creta is pricier).
    Here are a few reasons why:
    – Except for the rear side doors the exterior has nothing similar to mobilio.
    – Despite being a 7 seater it’s got ample leg space for passengers even if the front two seats are fully stretched back to accomodate a tall person.
    – The adaptability and suspension of the BR-V is amazing, which both duster and Creta fail to live up to. Especially in the Creta (like all hyundai cars) you can literally feel every bump and pothole which is a big turn off for an SUV.
    – there were few who voiced complaints about Honda retaining the same engine and not refining the diesel variant. Except for the slightly higher engine noise, honestly there is nothing much to complain. In the city, the pick up of BRV is quite smooth compared to Duster or Creta.
    – Honda is able to boast of a 21.9kmpl mileage only and bringing an automatic variant might not give it that edge which it currently has. After all the biggest drawback of Honda’s most successful SUV the CrV was the Low mileage wasn’t it! Only makes sense Honda is treading the path carefully now.
    – the Exteriors have been splashed with chrome fittings and the rear tail lights of the CRV is a class apart.
    -the interiors are pretty decent, pragmatic and comfortable and comes in an all-black colour that helps in easy maintenance.
    -as always Honda’s seats are the most comfortable amongst the three, with Duster coming second and Creta having a well known hyundai seating discomfort.
    Between Brv and Creta its obvious that two top the choice list. If ur all up for some flashy fun then Creta might be your preferred choice. But if ur looking for a sturdy and reliable car which is ergonomically designed for user comfort and perhaps the most pragmatic in the segment, then BR-V is your choice.

  6. Which suv should I buy among creta , duster, terrano, brv
    Pls suggest me and what should I opt for diesel ya petrol engine

LEAVE A REPLY